Welcome to The Forum SA. As a visitor you have read only access to the public content areas of this website. You will have to register as a member to access all content, post messages and network with our members. Membership is free and registering is quick and easy. You can click here to register now and become a member within minutes.
Which sport is more popular in SA - Rugby or Cricket?
We have a stereotyped view of South African men as keen on sport; this stereotype has been confirmed by my experience and so it is good to meet someone who doesn’t conform to it. My understanding is that Rugby and Cricket are widely played in schools on SA and so you must have had them foisted on you at some stage. I enjoyed the former but was rubbish at the latter.
I went to an Afrikaans primary school and an English high school. The primary school was big into rugby and the boys didn't play much else. The high school that I attended played soccer and cricket.
My dad was an orthopedic surgeon and he despised rugby with a passion - reason being that he continually had to treat schoolboys with broken necks and serious injuries mostly due to collapsed scrums and high tackles.
I can watch international soccer (football) because I find it to be a very fast tactical sport.
I don't like rugby - its such a stop start thing - kick the ball out that side - stand around - run to the other side - bash a guy, crawl around holding onto one another pants - break a neck, kick a ball out on the other side - stand around again...doesn't flow.
Cricket - walk up - knock a ball - have tea - stand around - scratch your nuts - chat - throw a ball - run a bit - have tea.....not for me.
Different communities have different sporting preferences, depending on available facilities. Traditional white schools play rugby and cricket and also athletics, but more schools now include other sports, depending on the availability of coaches and facilities. This may include sports such as hockey and surfing and even golf.
In more disadvantaged communities with no facilities, soccer or football is more widely played. This is evident in the poor performance of the national soccer team, as youngsters are not properly coached from an early age. Their training mostly start when they join a snr soccer club. We all know that it takes about 10 years to become a master of your art, whether it be sport, or any other skills.
I went to an Afrikaans primary school and an English high school. The primary school was big into rugby and the boys didn't play much else. The high school that I attended played soccer and cricket.
My dad was an orthopedic surgeon and he despised rugby with a passion - reason being that he continually had to treat schoolboys with broken necks and serious injuries mostly due to collapsed scrums and high tackles.
I can watch international soccer (football) because I find it to be a very fast tactical sport.
I don't like rugby - its such a stop start thing - kick the ball out that side - stand around - run to the other side - bash a guy, crawl around holding onto one another pants - break a neck, kick a ball out on the other side - stand around again...doesn't flow.
Cricket - walk up - knock a ball - have tea - stand around - scratch your nuts - chat - throw a ball - run a bit - have tea.....not for me.
It’s interesting to hear that the Afrikaans school played Rugby whereas the English school played Soccer and Cricket.
I don’t know whether that denotes a cultural difference?
I went to a private boys’ school divided into Houses and was lucky (or unlucky you might say) enough to be chosen to play Rugby for a House team. My Housemaster was a Rugby fanatic and so there was some prestige in being in the ‘Rugger team’ - it was considered more important than academic achievement! Once in you had to stay, even when you had crucial exams coming up. I continued with it (out of masochism?) as an undergraduate. There was actually a lot about it that I enjoyed and I had some great teammates and coaches. My injuries were only minor and put me out of action for a few weeks at most. There is a lot of fairness however in your father’s assessment and your caricature!
Your caricature of Cricket is also accurate, but then I was never much good at it; I liked the tea and I liked wearing Cricket jumpers but that’s about it. I used to enjoy watching it but it’s become a bit tacky and corporate now.
We didn’t play Soccer and so it wasn’t a strong part of my upbringing.
Different communities have different sporting preferences, depending on available facilities. Traditional white schools play rugby and cricket and also athletics, but more schools now include other sports, depending on the availability of coaches and facilities. This may include sports such as hockey and surfing and even golf.
In more disadvantaged communities with no facilities, soccer or football is more widely played. This is evident in the poor performance of the national soccer team, as youngsters are not properly coached from an early age. Their training mostly start when they join a snr soccer club. We all know that it takes about 10 years to become a master of your art, whether it be sport, or any other skills.
There’s something of a division - or has been - here as well, in that private boys’ schools have tended to play Rugby (‘Rugger’) rather than Football (Soccer). That was my experience and is still the case to a large extent.
I had wondered why the national Soccer team in SA seemed to be under-resourced in comparison with Cricket and Rugby. I also greatly admire the determination of those Soccer players who come from economically deprived communities with few facilities but persist anyway.
Soccer certainly has very deep roots in English popular culture and is one of our greatest global exports.
Rugby is also very much an English sport by origin, but seems to have a stronger following in NZ, France, parts of Spain (the Basque Country for example), parts of Northern Italy, South America and clearly among Afrikaners more than other South Africans.
Growing up Rugby was always seen as an Afrikaans sport and Soccer as English. I don't think I've ever encountered an Afrikaans soccer player.
When I was at school, soccer players were regarded as sissies. My opinion has not changed much, seeing that soccer is such a dangerous sport that players fall down in agony when an opposing player just frown at them. Rugby appears to be a much safer sport where players take the tackles and put their bodies on the line for their team without crying about it.
When I was at school, soccer players were regarded as sissies. My opinion has not changed much, seeing that soccer is such a dangerous sport that players fall down in agony when an opposing player just frown at them. Rugby appears to be a much safer sport where players take the tackles and put their bodies on the line for their team without crying about it.
@Douglas Lees - Today I will teach you a truly South African saying: "JaWellNoFine" - I will translate this into 14 year old teenage girl speak: "Whatever"
@Douglas Lees - Today I will teach you a truly South African saying: "JaWellNoFine" - I will translate this into 14 year old teenage girl speak: "Whatever"
Thanks for that - I like it! May I point out that the comment about Soccer was from @Blurock!
When I was at school, soccer players were regarded as sissies. My opinion has not changed much, seeing that soccer is such a dangerous sport that players fall down in agony when an opposing player just frown at them. Rugby appears to be a much safer sport where players take the tackles and put their bodies on the line for their team without crying about it.
I don’t recall that attitude to Soccer at school because it wasn’t a school activity! My university was quite traditional as well and Rugby featured much more prominently. Soccer has become extremely corporate and bureaucratic; it is caught up in the ‘health and safety’ culture and has fewer genuine links with local communities. Rugby League in the North of England still has a strong community base and (although I am familiar with Rugby Union instead) I admire it for that.
We process personal data about users of our site, through the use of cookies and other technologies, to deliver our services, personalize advertising, and to analyze site activity. We may share certain information about our users with our advertising and analytics partners. For additional details, refer to our Privacy Policy.
By clicking "I AGREE" below, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our personal data processing and cookie practices as described therein. You also acknowledge that this forum may be hosted outside your country and you consent to the collection, storage, and processing of your data in the country where this forum is hosted.
Tweet
Comment